8.a TO2613 - An ordinance of the city commission of the City of Tamarac, Florida establishing "Limited Online Sales" as an accessory use in the MU-N (Mixed-Use Neighborhood), MU-C (Mixed-Use Corridor), MU-G (Mixed-Use General), and NC (Neighborhood Commercial) zoning districts; amending Chapter 10, Article 3, Section 10-3.2, entitled "Table of Allowed Uses", specifically Table 10-3.1: allowed uses for the inclusion of "Limited Online Sales"; and amending Section 10-3.4, entitled "Accessory Uses and Structures", to provide the use-specific standards regulating the "Limited Online Sales" use; and amending Chapter 10, Article 6, entitled "Rules of Construction and Definitions", specifically Section 10-6.2(E), entitled "Accessory Uses", of the City of Tamarac code of ordinances, to provide a definition for "Limited Online Sales"; providing for codification; providing for conflicts; providing for severability; and providing for an effective date.

[8.a TO2613 - An ordinance of the city commission of the City of Tamarac, Florida establishing "Limited Online Sales" as an accessory use in the MU-N (Mixed-Use Neighborhood), MU-C (Mixed-Use Corridor), MU-G (Mixed-Use General), and NC (Neighborhood Commercial) zoning districts; amending Chapter 10, Article 3, Section 10-3.2, entitled "Table of Allowed Uses", specifically Table 10-3.1: allowed uses for the inclusion of "Limited Online Sales"; and amending Section 10-3.4, entitled "Accessory Uses and Structures", to provide the use-specific standards regulating the "Limited Online Sales" use; and amending Chapter 10, Article 6, entitled "Rules of Construction and Definitions", specifically Section 10-6.2(E), entitled "Accessory Uses", of the City of Tamarac code of ordinances, to provide a definition for "Limited Online Sales"; providing for codification; providing for conflicts; providing for severability; and providing for an effective date.]

AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TAMARAC, FLORIDA, ESTABLISHING "LIMITED ONLINE SALES" AS AN ACCESSORY USE IN THE MU-N (MIXED-USE NEIGHBORHOOD), MU-C (MIXED-USE CORRIDOR), MUG (MIXED-USE GENERAL), AND NC (NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL) ZONING DISTRICTS; AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 3, SECTION 10-3.2, ENTITLED "TABLES OF ALLOWED USES", SPECIFICALLY TABLE 10-3.1: ALLOWED USES FOR THE INCLUSION OF "LIMITED ONLINE SALES"; AND AMENDING SECTION 10-3.4, ENTITLED "ACCESSORY USES AND STRUCTURES", TO PROVIDE THE USE-SPECIFIC STANDARD REGULATING THE "LIMITED ONLINE SALES" USE, AND AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 6, ENTITLED "RULES OF CONSTRUCTION AND DEFINITIONS", SPECIFICALLY SECTION 10-6.2 (E), ENTITLED "ACCESSORY USES", OF THE CITY OF TAMERA CODE OF ORDINANCES, TO PROVIDE A DEFINITION FOR "LIMITED ONLINE SALES"; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.

WELL. WE'LL NOW HAVE THE APPLICANT'S PRESENTATION.

CAN YOU STATE YOUR NAME AND COMPANY? YES, AND WELL DONE.

[INAUDIBLE] REPRESENTING THE APPLICANT, PATINA COLLECTIVE.

WE INITIATED THIS PROCESS THROUGH WHAT IS CALLED AN ESTABLISHMENT OF USE APPLICATION.

AND WHAT THAT MEANS IS, IN EVERY ZONING DISTRICT, THERE ARE A LIST OF USES THAT ARE PERMITTED BY RIGHT.

IN THIS CASE, IT'S AN ACCESSORY USE. AND WHERE IT'S NOT SPECIFICALLY LISTED, THERE'S A PROCESS TO HAVE THE CITY COMMISSION INTERPRET WHETHER AN ADDITIONAL USE SHOULD BE LISTED. IN THIS CASE, THIS IS A CAR MUSEUM.

IT'S A CLASSIC CAR MUSEUM. A MERCEDES BENZ PRE AMG MERGER MUSEUM STARTED BY CAR ENTHUSIASTS, SPECIFICALLY A MERCEDES BENZ ENTHUSIAST. [INAUDIBLE] IS THE PRINCIPAL.

AND SO THERE'S NO DISPUTE ABOUT THAT MUSEUM USE BEING ALLOWED.

IT'S JUST THE ACCESSORY COMPONENT. SO THERE'S RETAIL MERCHANDISE THAT DEALS WITH THE BRANDING NATURE OF PATINA COLLECTIVE. SO SHIRTS, HATS ALONG THAT NATURE THAT'S SOLD ON SITE BUT ALSO ONLINE.

ADDITIONALLY, THERE ARE SOME CARS THAT ARE CYCLED OUT OF THE COLLECTION AND SO THAT PERTAINS TO ONLINE SALES, RIGHT? WITH REGARD TO THE CARS, IT'S EXCLUSIVELY ONLINE.

THE CITY WANTED TO BE ON THE SIDE OF CAUTION, WHICH I UNDERSTAND THEY WANTED TO HAVE THIS TO BE CONFIRMED AS A CATEGORY THAT WAS AUTHORIZED. SO THIS IS THE PROCESS TO DO THAT.

IN ORDER TO SORT OF KILL TWO BIRDS WITH ONE STONE, STAFF HAS ELECTED TO ALSO DO A TEXT AMENDMENT, THAT'S WHAT'S BEFORE YOU NOW. SO IT ESSENTIALLY ADDRESSES OUR REQUEST, WHICH IS TO HAVE THE CITY COMMISSION INTERPRET THE CODE IS ALLOWING FOR THE ONLINE SALES USE, BUT IT ALSO IS GOING TO BE EFFECTUATED THROUGH A TEXT AMENDMENT WHICH WOULD NOT JUST PERTAIN TO OUR PROPERTY OR OUR ZONING DISTRICT, BUT TO ALL ZONING DISTRICTS WITH REGARD TO THE ONLINE SALES CATEGORY AS AN ACCESSORY USE.

SO I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE WE'RE ON THE SAME PAGE AS FAR AS WHAT WE'RE ASKING, WHAT WE'RE HERE FOR.

THAT'S WHY IT'S A LEGISLATIVE REQUEST, BECAUSE IT'S A TEXT AMENDMENT.

THIS IS THE LOCATION. IT'S NOT YET OPEN. IT'S BEEN ONGOING TO OPEN THIS SINCE ROUGHLY 2023.

THIS USED TO BE. SO THE PATINA COLLECTIVE WAS SOMETHING.

JUST BACKING UP REAL QUICK. IT'S A CONCEPT THAT WAS CREATED.

A COMPANY WAS CREATED IN 2019. [INAUDIBLE] WAS A COUPLE PARTNERS OF HIS, AND HE'S A CLASSIC MERCEDES BENZ CLASSIC CAR ENTHUSIAST. HE'S HAD HIS OWN PERSONAL COLLECTION IN THE PAST, AND, HAVING BEEN IN A DIFFERENT INDUSTRY ENTIRELY, DECIDED TO FOLLOW HIS PASSION AND CREATE THE WORLD'S LARGEST MERCEDES BENZ CLASSIC VEHICLE MUSEUM.

[00:10:06]

AND THIS IS THE LOCATION WHERE HE CHOSE TO OPEN IT.

HE'S HAD. INITIALLY THERE WAS A LOCATION WHEN THIS FIRST STARTED OUT.

INITIALLY, IT WAS LIKE A YOUTUBE CHANNEL WHERE HE JUST HAD SOME BRANDED CONTENT TO PROMOTE THE IDEA OF PRESERVING AN ERA, YOU KNOW, CULTURAL ICONS OR WHAT THESE VEHICLES ARE TO A LOT OF PEOPLE.

AND IT WENT FROM A YOUTUBE CHANNEL TO ALL OF A SUDDEN HAVING A LOCATION.

ITS FIRST LOCATION WAS IN LAKE WORTH. IT WAS ABOUT 5000FT², THEN HAD ANOTHER LOCATION IN BOCA RATON, ROUGHLY 20,000FT². THE COLLECTION GREW. IT WAS NO LONGER A PERSONAL.

IT STARTED OUT BEFORE EVEN ITS FIRST LOCATION AS IS A PERSONAL COLLECTION, BUT THEN IT TURNED INTO, HEY, THESE VEHICLES ARE AROUND THE WORLD. YOU KNOW, THEY'VE BEEN DRIVEN IN THE PAST AND DISPLAYED ON TV, IN HIP HOP VIDEOS YOU KNOW, CROWN PRINCES, SULTANS IN THE MIDDLE EAST DROVE THEM, YOU KNOW, VARIOUS PUBLIC FIGURES POPULARIZED THESE VEHICLES AND TURNED THEM INTO CULTURAL ICONS THAT THEY BECAME IN THE 1980S AND 1990S.

THAT ERA IS WHAT THIS MUSEUM SEEKS TO PRESERVE, AND THERE'S A LOT OF EXCITEMENT ABOUT IT.

YOU KNOW, WE'RE NOT ALL FAMILIAR WITH MERCEDES BENZ TO THE EXTENT THAT ENTHUSIASTS ARE, RIGHT? BUT THERE'S A LOT OF INTEREST. I MEAN, DENNIS RODMAN, PUBLIC FIGURES OF, WELL, WHO ARE WELL KNOWN ARE TAKING AN INTEREST.

YOU KNOW, DENNIS RODMAN CAME OUT THE OTHER DAY, MIKE TYSON CAME OUT.

THE CEO OF MERCEDES BENZ INTERNATIONALLY CAME OUT.

THERE ARE SOME OTHERS. I HAD SOME NAMES I WANTED TO SAY.

THERE WERE SOME OTHER RECOGNIZABLE NAMES THAT HAVE SHOWN UP RECENTLY.

THERE WAS AN F1 RACING DRIVER WHO CAME OUT BECAUSE THEY'RE DOING THAT IN MIAMI NOW.

AND SO WHAT THE PATINA COLLECTIVE DOES, THEY DO SOME DISPLAYING DURING THE F1 EVENTS.

SO WITH THAT BACKDROP THAT'S WHAT'S HAPPENING HERE.

THAT'S WHAT THIS IS ABOUT. SO IT USED TO BE A BAER'S FURNITURE STORE.

THIS IS LOCATED AT. OKAY. SOME RECOGNITION WHERE THIS IS, RIGHT? THIS IS AROUND 441 JUST SOUTH OF COMMERCIAL BOULEVARD, OKAY? AND THIS IS A STRIP THAT IS KIND OF BLIGHTED NOWADAYS.

IT'S KIND OF BECOME A LITTLE BLIGHTED, YOU KNOW, AND IT'S.

THESE ARE JUST OLDER STRUCTURES THAT HAVEN'T REALLY BEEN INVESTED INTO VERY MUCH.

JUST TO THE NORTH, THERE'S TWO PARCELS THAT ARE FORMERLY OWNED BY A CHURCH THAT HAVE FALLEN INTO DISREPAIR.

THERE WAS SOME HOMELESS ENCAMPMENT ISSUES THERE.

IT'S BEEN TAKEN OVER BY THE CITY. BUT THIS IS A STRIP THAT IS JUST IN NEED OF REVITALIZATION.

IT'S IN NEED OF COMMUNITY, OF RESTORATION, OF INVESTMENT.

AND THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO BRING JUST THAT, A VERY UNIQUE USE, DIFFICULT TO CATEGORIZE.

MANY CITIES, BUT NEVERTHELESS A VERY. I THINK AN OVERALL BENEFIT TO THE CITY, NO QUESTION.

SO JUST ABOUT THE BUSINESS MODEL, WHAT THIS IS MORE ABOUT.

HOW DO THEY EARN MONEY. LIKE WHAT IS THIS ABOUT, RIGHT? SO AGAIN, PASSION PROJECT. THAT'S WHAT IT STARTED OUT AS.

IT TURNED INTO THE WORLD'S LARGEST MERCEDES BENZ CLASSIC VEHICLE MUSEUM.

AND AGAIN, THEY FOCUS PRIMARILY ON 3 AMG MERGER MERCEDES BENZ, WHICH IS LIKE I THINK 1990S, 1980S. YOU WE'VE ALL SEEN THEM ON TV GROWING UP, AND THERE'S ALSO RACE CARS FROM LIKE THE 1970S THAT WILL COME INTO CIRCULATION IN THEIR COLLECTION.

BUT MOST OF THE REVENUE FOR THE PATINA COLLECTIVE IS ACTUALLY THROUGH ONLINE MULTIMEDIA CONTENT.

SO YOUTUBE, INSTAGRAM, X, VARIOUS SOCIAL MEDIA, WEB, YOU KNOW, SOURCES.

YOU'LL SEE VIDEOS FROM THEM ONLINE. THEY HAVE ABOUT 100,000 FOLLOWERS ONLINE.

I'M SORRY, 2 MILLION HITS PER YEAR ONLINE. IT'S BECOMING A.

THERE'S A LOT OF EXCITEMENT SURROUNDING PATINA COLLECTIVE IN THE ENTHUSIAST COMMUNITY FOR CLASSIC MERCEDES BENZ VEHICLES.

AND SO THAT'S A LOT OF THE REVENUE COMES FROM THAT.

THEY ALSO HAVE, YOU KNOW, BRANDED MERCHANDISE THAT THEY SELL.

THEY SELL IT ON SITE. BUT AGAIN, ON SITE, I HAVEN'T MENTIONED THIS, BUT ON SITE IT'S APPOINTMENT ONLY.

SO THIS IS INTENDED TO BE AN EXCLUSIVE EXPERIENCE, YOU KNOW? THERE'S REGULAR TICKETS FOR THOSE WHO MAKE AN APPOINTMENT SHOW UP.

THERE'S ALSO VIP TICKETS FOR THOSE WHO WANT TO MEET THE OWNER, [INAUDIBLE], AND OTHERS WHO ARE INVOLVED IN THE COLLECTION, AND TO HAVE A PERSONAL TOUR OF CERTAIN VEHICLES.

THAT AND THE BACKSTORIES ON THEM, LIKE WHO DROVE THEM, YOU KNOW, WHAT VIDEOS THEY WERE DISPLAYED IN,

[00:15:02]

AND WHATEVER HIP HOP VIDEO OR WHATEVER INTERNATIONALLY BROADCAST EVENT IT MAY HAVE BEEN IN.

SO PEOPLE ARE LIKE FROTHING, YOU KNOW, FOR THIS THING TO OPEN.

AND IT'S BEEN KIND OF A TWO YEAR PROCESS. THERE'S BEEN SOME DELAYS.

YOU KNOW, AGAIN, IT'S DIFFICULT TO CATEGORIZE BECAUSE IT'S NOT A COMMON USE.

BUT WE'RE BASICALLY THERE. AND THE LAST HURDLE IS JUST IDENTIFYING THIS ISSUE OF A LIMITED ONLINE SALES USE AND HOW THAT FITS WITHIN THE EXISTING CODE. SO THIS IS THE FLOOR PLAN.

IT'S ABOUT 46,000FT². SO THEIR LAST SITE IN BOCA WAS ROUGHLY 20,000.

THIS IS. THEIR COLLECTION HAS GROWN. THEY NEED MORE SPACE.

AND PATINA COLLECTIVE INTENDS FOR THIS TO BE THEIR LONG TERM HOME.

TOWARD THE FRONT, WHICH IS THE TOP OF THIS IMAGE.

THESE VEHICLES ARE ON DISPLAY. THERE WILL BE.

LIKE A NORMAL MUSEUM, THERE'S GOING TO BE DIFFERENT DISPLAYS THAT WILL CYCLE THROUGH.

THERE MIGHT BE LIKE AN AMG COLLECTION FROM LIKE LATE 1990S ON DISPLAY.

THAT IS THE FOCUS OF HOW THE VEHICLES ARE ARRANGED.

SO THAT'S HOW THOSE VEHICLES ARE ARRANGED IN THE FRONT. TOWARD THE BACK ARE VEHICLES THAT ARE STORED AND THAT WILL BE CYCLED IN AND OUT OF DISPLAY.

SO ABOUT 5% OF THE VEHICLES THAT ARE IN THE BACK IN TOTAL, ACTUALLY, ANNUALLY ARE GOING TO BE AVAILABLE FOR SALE.

AND THE REASON THAT THEY HAVE TO BE SOLD IS, THERE'S ALWAYS AN INTEREST IN FINDING THE NEXT BEST MODEL THAT'S OUT THERE THAT, YOU KNOW, PRICED MODEL THAT THERE'S A LOT OF EXCITEMENT AROUND, YOU KNOW, THAT MAYBE IS RARE. THERE MIGHT BE ONLY 50 TO 100.

I WISH I WAS, YOU KNOW, SPECIALIZED ENOUGH TO BE ABLE TO RECITE THE INDIVIDUAL MODEL NUMBERS TO YOU OF EACH ONE.

I CAN'T DO THAT. BUT THIS IS HOW THE MODEL WORKS.

SO THE WAY THAT THE VEHICLES ARE SOLD IS ONLINE.

THEY ARE NOT MARKETED ON SITE. THERE'S NO DISPLAY FOR SALES ON SITE.

THERE'S AN AUCTION THAT HAPPENS FOR THOSE VEHICLES.

THE MAJORITY OF THEM ARE INTERNATIONALLY PURCHASED AND ARE SHIPPED OUT.

THERE'S NO TEST DRIVING ON SITE OCCASIONALLY.

THOSE WHO ARE INTERESTED IN AN ONLINE AUCTION MIGHT COME AND VIEW IT IN PERSON, BUT THAT'S RARE.

AGAIN, MOST OF IT IS INTERNATIONALLY PURCHASED, SO THIS IS JUST A NECESSARY COMPONENT OF THIS MUSEUM BECAUSE OF THE FACT THAT YOU HAVE TO CYCLE IN AND OUT INVENTORY TO KEEP THE DISPLAYS FRESH, LIKE ANY MUSEUM, THERE'S GOING TO BE PORTIONS THAT ARE UPDATED REGULARLY.

AND THAT'S KIND OF HOW THIS WORKS AS WELL. THIS IS A NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL ZONING.

AGAIN, MUSEUM IS PERMITTED IN THAT ZONING, AS YOU CAN SEE HERE.

THE ACCESSORY USES THAT WE ARE CLAIMING IS. SO THIS IS JUST BACKSTORY.

IT'S NOT REALLY NECESSARY FOR THE TEXT AMENDMENT THAT YOU'RE CONSIDERING, BUT WE INITIATED THIS APPLICATION BY ASKING FOR AN INTERPRETATION THAT, THIS LIMITED ONLINE SALES USE IS ALREADY INCLUDED WITHIN THE OTHER ACCESSORY USES CATEGORY, BECAUSE RETAIL CAN BE AN ACCESSORY USED TO ONLINE RETAIL CAN BE AN ACCESSORY USED TO, WE BELIEVE.

BUT THE CITY WANTED TO JUST MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE A SEPARATE CARVEOUT FOR THAT.

AND THAT IS THE REASON FOR THE TEXT AMENDMENT. THESE ARE SOME OF THE MERCHANDISE, THE SHIRTS, THE HATS THAT WILL BE, YOU KNOW, THESE ARE BOUGHT IN BULK.

I MEAN, PEOPLE REALLY ARE EXCITED ABOUT THIS.

THIS MUSEUM, THIS COLLECTION INTERNATIONALLY AND NATIONALLY AND LOCALLY.

THE ONLINE PROCESS, JUST GOING THROUGH THE STEPS.

I MEAN, IT'S ONLINE ORDERS, DEPOSITS ARE TAKEN.

THERE'S A TRUCKING COMPANY THAT DELIVERS IT. AND THEN, YOU KNOW, THERE'S FINAL PAYMENT.

IT'S REALLY NOT TOO COMPLICATED. MOST OF THE VEHICLES ARE DELIVERED TO, OR ARE SHIPPED THROUGH PORT EVERGLADES OUT OF COUNTRY.

SO THAT'S HOW THAT WORKS. THIS IS NOTHING NEW, THE CONCEPT OF ONLINE SALES.

THIS IS A PRETTY COMMON FEATURE OF TODAY'S MARKETPLACE.

BARNES AND NOBLE, I THINK IKEA MUSEUM'S IN THE AREA, PEREZ ART MUSEUM IN MIAMI, NSU ART MUSEUM IN FORT LAUDERDALE, ALL OF THEM. ALL OF THESE BUSINESSES AND MANY MORE HAVE ONLINE SALES CATEGORIES.

THIS IS NOT A BIG ASK IN MY VIEW. THE CITY WANTS TO MAKE SURE TO MODERNIZE ITS CODE AND PART OF ENSURING CONTINUING INVESTMENT INTO THE COMMUNITIES AND ENSURING A MODERNIZED CODE THAT ACCOMMODATES THE REALITIES OF THE CURRENT ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT.

[00:20:02]

SO JUST THE STANDARDS OF REVIEW THAT ARE APPLICABLE TO THE INTERPRETATION THAT WE'RE SEEKING WHICH, YOU KNOW, I DON'T THINK IS NECESSARILY DIRECTLY MATERIAL TO THE TEXT AMENDMENT, BUT NEVERTHELESS, THESE APPLICATIONS ARE BEING, YOU KNOW, OUR REQUEST FOR INTERPRETATION AND THE TEXT AMENDMENT IS MERGED INTO ONE FOR PURPOSES OF WHAT'S BEFORE YOU.

SO THE MAIN ONE IS REALLY THE NATURE OF THE USE AND WHAT IT INVOLVES.

AND THAT'S A CONSIDERATION. I THINK THE PURPOSE OF THAT IS TO JUST IDENTIFY, DOES THIS SEEM COMPATIBLE WITH EXISTING ACCESSORY USES? SO RETAIL CAN BE AN ACCESSORY USE.

THERE'S A GENERAL CATEGORY FOR OTHER ACCESSORY USES.

WE HAVE TO BE AWARE OF THAT. NEARLY 100% OF BUSINESSES OUT THERE WITH BRICK AND MORTAR LOCATIONS ARE GOING TO HAVE ONLINE SALES COMPONENTS.

SO I THINK THE NATURE OF THIS USE IS REALLY NOT ANYTHING THAT IS INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE EXISTING CODE.

AND FOR THAT REASON, THAT CONSIDERATION IS FAVORABLE TO AN APPROVAL.

ANTICIPATED EMPLOYMENT. THIS IS NOT GOING TO BE A SOURCE OF TRAFFIC REALLY, OR ANYTHING OR OR INTENSITY.

I MEAN, THERE'S 3 TO 4 EMPLOYEES THAT ARE GOING TO BE WORKING THIS LOCATION.

IT'S EMPLOYMENT ONLY. THAT'S A BIG PART OF WHY.

SO IT'S NOT REALLY GOING TO BE LIKE A TON OF CARS COMING IN AND OUT OF THERE BY EMPLOYEES.

TRANSPORTATION. SAME. SAME SITUATION. THIS USED TO BE A FURNITURE STORE.

THERE'S A LOT MORE IN AND OUT TRAFFIC WHEN IT'S OPEN TO THE PUBLIC. KIND OF ESTABLISHMENT.

THIS IS GOING TO BE APPOINTMENT ONLY, WHICH IS A BIG DIFFERENCE. THE AMOUNT OF NOISE.

NO DIFFERENT THAN A BEARS FURNITURE STORE. EVERYTHING.

EVERYTHING'S INSIDE. JUST LIKE WITH BEARS. AND AGAIN, THERE'S NOTHING.

THERE'S NOT GOING TO BE ANY KIND OF TEST DRIVING OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT THAT WOULD HAVE THAT WOULD GIVE CONCERNS OVER LIKE INTENSITY ISSUES OR INCOMPATIBILITY ISSUES.

LET ME GO BACK. ACTUALLY, THE GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR PUBLIC UTILITIES, THERE'S NOT GOING TO BE ANYTHING ADDITIONAL, NOT ANYTHING MATERIALLY ADDITIONAL FROM THIS USE, ESPECIALLY ON ONLINE SALES. SO JUST TO SUM IT UP, THE PROPERTY IS GOING TO BE A UNIQUE USE. AND THERE'S REALLY ONLY ONE OTHER MUSEUM I COULD THINK OF IN, BROWARD OF THIS KIND, BUT IT'S STILL DIFFERENT. IT'S IN SUNRISE. I DON'T KNOW IF ANY OF YOU HAVE BEEN TO IT.

I FORGOT THE NAME. STARTS WITH D, BUT IT'S PRETTY COOL.

IT'S 60S AND 70S AND 50S CARS, AND IT'S GOT LIKE, MEMORABILIA FROM A TIME PERIOD TO WHEN THOSE CARS WERE MADE.

AND THAT'S SORT OF. BUT THIS IS NOT LIKE THAT.

IT'S FOCUSED ON MERCEDES. IT'S NOT JUST THAT, BUT IT'S THE CULTURAL ERA OF THAT TIME.

YOU KNOW, IT'S THE MEMORABILIA THAT GOES ALONG WITH THOSE VEHICLES AND THE ERA THAT THEY WERE MADE IN.

THESE ARE CULTURAL ICONS THAT WE CAN IDENTIFY WITH IN OUR OWN WAY.

AND THE EXPERIENCES EACH OF US HAD GROWING UP AND THE KIND OF MUSIC WE FOLLOWED, ETC.

AND THE FACT THAT ONLY 5% OF THE VEHICLE SALES ARE GOING TO.

THE VEHICLES ARE GOING TO BE AVAILABLE FOR ONLINE AUCTION, I THINK MAKES IT CLEAR THAT THE INTENSITY IS NOT GOING TO BE ANY CONCERN FOR THE COMMUNITY. IT'S A NET GAIN, NET BENEFIT FOR THE COMMUNITY.

HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU FOR LISTENING.

THANK YOU. THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD? NO? IS THERE AN EDUCATIONAL COMPONENT? I THINK PRIMARILY WITH THE VIP PASSES THAT THEY OFFER, YES.

SO THAT WOULD BE. OTHER THAN THE MULTIMEDIA CONTENT THAT'S AVAILABLE ONLINE, YOU CAN LOOK UP VARIOUS YOUTUBE VIDEOS FROM PATINA COLLECTIVE.

THEY PUT OUT A LOT OF CONTENT ON YOUTUBE AND, YOU KNOW, QUALITY VIDEOS THAT THEY PUT TOGETHER THAT TALK ABOUT THE BACKSTORY OF SOME OF THEIR CARS. SO IN THAT WAY, THE EDUCATION IS MADE AVAILABLE TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC, AND THAT'S HOW PEOPLE ARE AWARE OF IT.

AND THEN THEY COME IN AND THEY VIEW IT. AND THAT GENERATES, YOU TICKET SALES, BUT MOST OF IT COMES FROM JUST THE ONLINE MULTIMEDIA CONTENT, REVENUE FROM ADS AND WHATNOT. BUT FOR THE VIP TICKETS, FOR EXAMPLE, THERE WILL BE PRIVATE MEETINGS WITH THE OWNERSHIP.

THEY'LL TAKE THEM AROUND THE STORE, THEY'LL INTRODUCE THEM TO VARIOUS VEHICLES AND THEIR HISTORY, LIKE WHO DROVE THEM. WHEN IT WAS CREATED, YOU KNOW, BEFORE 1999, WHEN AMG WAS MERGED WITH MERCEDES, THESE VEHICLES WERE CUSTOMIZED AND THEY WERE UNIQUE.

AMG WAS A MONOPOLY, IN TERMS OF SOME.

[00:25:04]

I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO CALL IT, LIKE MANUFACTURER OR CUSTOMIZED SHOP THAT JUST DEALT WITH MAKING VEHICLES UNIQUE, ADDING FEATURES TO THEM THAT MADE THEM UNIQUE.

AND SO THIS MUSEUM FOCUSES ON AMG COLLECTION BEFORE IT WAS MERGED, WHEN EACH VEHICLE WAS TOTALLY UNIQUE.

I THINK THEY CALL THEM COACHBUILT. CUSTOM BUILT VEHICLES.

THE CHASSIS ARE PRE-MADE, BUT THE OUTSIDE IS CUSTOMIZED.

AND SO, YOU KNOW, THE WAY THEY WERE MADE, THE STORY BEHIND WHO DROVE THEM, THAT SORT OF THING.

AND THE WAYS THAT THEY BECAME PROMINENT IN, YOU KNOW, THE CULTURAL EXPERIENCE THAT WE ALL HAVE, WHETHER IT'S BY WHATEVER PROMINENTLY HIP HOP, YOU KNOW, AND SOME OTHER, YOU KNOW, WWE WRESTLERS WOULD DRIVE THEM AROUND A LOT.

SO JUST TALKING ABOUT THE BACKSTORY. SO IN THAT WAY, YES.

TO GIVE YOU A VERY LONG ANSWER. HOW LARGE IS YOUR STAFF? 3 TO 4 PEOPLE ON SITE. IN TERMS OF PARKING, WHEN YOU HAVE EVENTS, IS IT APPROPRIATE IN TERMS OF, OR DOES THAT BECOME A NUISANCE? NO, THERE'A NO INTENTION TO REALLY HAVE LIKE EVENTS AT THIS SITE.

EVENTS ARE OFF SITE WHEN THEY DO. LIKE I GAVE AN EXAMPLE OF F1 RACES THAT HAPPENED IN MIAMI.

THEY'LL SET UP AN EVENT OVER THERE, RIGHT? BUT ON SITE THEY LIMIT IT TO LIKE TWO AT A TIME FOR THEIR APPOINTMENTS.

IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE AN EXPERIENCE AND NOT SOMETHING THAT YOU'RE BUMPING INTO PEOPLE WHILE DOING, AND IT WORKS. AGAIN, MOST OF THE REVENUE COMES FROM ONLINE MULTIMEDIA CONTENT.

SO IT'S JUST LIKE AN ADDITIONAL EXPOSURE THAT PEOPLE WHO ARE REALLY INTO IT WILL PAY FOR AND COME THERE FOR AND CONTINUE TO TALK ABOUT IT ONLINE AND SPREAD THE WORD, YOU KNOW. AND SO THEY'RE FOLLOWING GROWS EVERY YEAR ONLINE.

YOU KNOW, 2 MILLION HITS PER YEAR IS NOT NOTHING.

AND SO THAT'S HOW THEY CREATE THAT ADDITIONAL EXPOSURE.

OKAY. THANK YOU. I HAVE A QUESTION. SURE. BUT I'M NOT SURE IF IT'S DIRECTED TO YOU OR THE CITY.

THE ONLINE COMPONENT, IS IT JUST BECAUSE THEY'RE SELLING THE CARS, RIGHT? AND IT'S NOT TRYING TO BE CATEGORIZED AS A CAR DEALERSHIP OR CAR SALES.

IS THAT WHY THIS IS COMING? EXCUSE ME. FOR THE RECORD, CHRISTIAN WATERVAL, CITY PLANNER, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT.

I'LL BE ADDRESSING THAT IN THE STAFF PRESENTATION.

OKAY, GOOD. OKAY, AND THEN MY OTHER QUESTION TO YOU OR THE CITY IS, WILL THERE BE ANY SPECIAL MODIFICATION TO THE BUILDING OR THE AC SYSTEM SEEING THAT WE'RE BRINGING THE CARS IN, CARBON MONOXIDE? I DON'T KNOW IF YOU'LL BE ADDRESSING THAT. I CAN ANSWER THAT. ACTUALLY, HE CAN MAYBE FOLLOW. CHRISTIAN COULD MAYBE FOLLOW UP ON THAT, BUT NOT ANY MAJOR WAY. ALL THE REGULATIONS ARE BEING FOLLOWED.

SO THERE HAS TO BE A NEW CO BECAUSE IT IS A CHANGE OF USE FROM RETAIL TO, YOU KNOW, TO THE MUSEUM USE.

BUT IT'S NOT GOING TO BE A WHOLESALE CHANGE OF THE STRUCTURE.

IT'S JUST MODIFICATIONS TO COMPLY WITH BUILDING CODE.

I KNOW, BECAUSE JUST GETTING THE CARS IN POSITION, AND, YOU KNOW, IF YOU GO TO THE SHOWS, YOU HAVE TO DRIVE THEM OUT. AND IT'S INSIDE AN AC BUILDING.

IN THE PAST, WHEN I'VE WORKED ON PROJECTS, I'VE BEEN. WE'VE WORKED CLOSELY.

DID. WE WORKED CLOSELY WITH THE FIRE DEPARTMENT.

ACTUALLY, THAT WAS THE REASON FOR A LOT OF THE DELAYS, JUST FIGURING OUT HOW TO CATEGORIZE IT AND WHAT SAFETY PROTOCOLS WERE REQUIRED FOR THIS, BECAUSE IT'S SO UNIQUE AND WE'RE ALL ON. FIRE DEPARTMENT'S ON BOARD NOW.

IT'S JUST LIKE THE LAST HURDLE, JUST HOW.

I AM FINE. OKAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT? NOPE. I THINK THAT'S A BEAUTIFUL ADDITION TO THE CITY OF TAMARAC, AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO SEE PRESENTATION FROM THE CITY.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR LISTENING. I DID HAVE A QUESTION.

I'M SORRY. SHE HAS A QUESTION. OH SHE DID. SO I GUESS, BACK TO WHAT SHE WAS KIND OF ASKING, AS IT RELATES TO THE VEHICLES THAT ARE USED FOR THE MUSEUM, HOW OFTEN ARE THEY LIKE, SWATTED OUT OR TRANSITIONED OUT IN AND OUT OF THE BUILDING? SO. WHAT PERCENTAGE, I GUESS, OF THE VEHICLES? SO IT'S 5% PER YEAR. PER YEAR. ROUGHLY 5% PER YEAR.

YOU DID MENTION THAT BEFORE. OKAY. YEAH. OKAY, GREAT.

OKAY. GOOD MORNING AGAIN. FOR THE RECORD, CHRISTIAN WATERVAL, CITY PLANNER, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT, CITY OF TAMARAC.

WE'RE HERE TODAY FOR THE PATINA COLLECTIVE, LLC.

CASE NO. 1-EOU-25 FOR ESTABLISHMENT OF USE. THE ESTABLISHMENT OF USE REQUEST IS TO ESTABLISH LIMITED ONLINE SALES AS AN ACCESSORY USE IN THE MUN, MIXED USE NEIGHBORHOOD, MUC, MIXED USE CORRIDOR, MUG, MIXED USE GENERAL, AND NC, NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL ZONING DISTRICTS.

ALSO, WE'RE HERE TODAY FOR THE APPROVAL OF A TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, SECTION 10-3.2,

[00:30:05]

TABLE 10-3.1: ALLOWED USES, SECTION 10-3.4: ACCESSORY USES AND USES IN STRUCTURES, AND SECTION 10-6.2: USE CATEGORIES AND USE TYPES DEFINE. THE FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION IS COMMERCIAL, THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION IS NC, NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL, AND THE COMMISSION DISTRICT IS GOVERNED BY DISTRICT 1 COMMISSIONER, MARLON BOLTON. THE ESTABLISHMENT OF USE APPLICABILITY.

THE ESTABLISHMENT OF USE APPLIES TO THE ESTABLISHMENT OF USES NOT CURRENTLY LISTED OR ADDRESSED WITHIN THIS CODE.

THE PURPOSE TODAY IS TO ESTABLISH LIMITED ONLINE SALES AS AN ACCESSORY USE WITHIN THE CITY TO ADDRESS EMERGING E-COMMERCE ACTIVITIES WHERE GOODS, PRODUCTS OR SERVICES ARE RECEIVED DIGITALLY OR DELIVERED EXCLUSIVELY TO CUSTOMERS OFF SITE.

THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE WILL BE UPDATED TO ACCOMMODATE AND REGULATE THESE NEW TYPE OF USES.

THE INTENT IS THE ESTABLISHMENT OF LIMITED ONLINE SALES AS AN ACCESSORY USE WITHIN THE FOUR ZONING DISTRICTS, AND THE CORRESPONDING AMENDMENT TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO REFLECT THE SAME.

IT WILL ENHANCE THE CITY'S ABILITY TO ATTRACT AND RETAIN CREATIVE AND INNOVATIVE BUSINESS VENTURES THAT STRENGTHEN ITS COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS.

THE TEXT AMENDMENTS. APPLICABILITY. THE PROCEDURES AND STANDARDS IN THIS SUBSECTION APPLIES TO THE REVIEW OF ANY PROPOSAL TO REVISE THE TEXT OF THIS CODE.

THE PURPOSE OF THE PROPOSED TEXT AMENDMENT IS TO, ONE, ADD LIMITED ONLINE SALES TO THE TABLE OF ALLOWED USES AND THE CORRESPONDING ZONING DISTRICTS. TWO, TO ADD THESE SPECIFIC USE STANDARDS TO REGULATE THE PROPOSED LIMITED ONLINE SALES USE TYPE, WHICH I'LL EXPLAIN LATER. AND THREE, THE ADDITION OF LIMITED ONLINE SALES USE TYPE DEFINITION.

AND THE INTENT IS TO ANALYZE AND WEIGH THE SIGNIFICANCE OF AMENDING THE TEXT OF THIS CODE, AND TO CONSIDER WHETHER AND TO WHAT DEGREE THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT IS NECESSARY.

PRESENTED IN FRONT OF YOU IS OUR CODE SECTION FOR ACCESSORY USES AND TABLE 10-3.1.

IT REFLECTS THAT LIMITED ONLINE SALES WILL BE ADDED TO THE MUN, MUC, MUG AND NC ZONING DISTRICTS AS ACCESSORIES ONLY, INCLUDING USE STANDARDS WHICH WILL REGULATE AGAIN THE USE IN SECTION 10-3.4, SUBSECTION D.8.

INCLUDING ALL THE NUMBERS SHIFT DOWN IN THE USE STANDARD.

SO THAT'S WHY YOU SEE A RED 9 NEXT TO THE USE STANDARD FOR OUTDOOR SPORTS FIELDS AND PLAYGROUNDS.

ALL THE NUMBERS SHIFT DOWN. 8, 9, 10 AND THEN CONSECUTIVELY.

SECTION 10-3.4. ACCESSORY USE AND STRUCTURES.

SO THE FOUR CONDITIONS THAT WE'RE GOING TO HAVE FOR THE USE STANDARDS OR FOR LIMITED ONLINE SALES.

A, THERE SHALL BE NO RETAIL COUNTER, SHOWROOM OR KIOSK ASSOCIATED WITH THIS USE WHERE IN-PERSON SALES OCCUR ON SITE.

B, NO WALK-IN SOLICITATION, ADVERTISEMENT DISPLAY OR MARKETING DISPLAYS ORIENTED TO PASSERBY SHALL OCCUR ON SITE, INTERNALLY OR EXTERNALLY. C, IF GOODS ARE STORED ON SITE FOR DISPATCH, THE STORE SHALL BE ENTIRELY INTERNAL AND NO EXTERNAL DISPLAY OF GOODS, INVENTORY OR TRUCK STAGING VISIBLE FROM THE STREET OR ADJACENT PROPERTIES SHALL BE ALLOWED.

D, SIGNAGE SHALL BE LIMITED TO STANDARD BUILDING SIGNAGE PERMITTED FOR THE PRINCIPAL USE.

NO ADDITIONAL ADVERTISING, SIGNAGE OR DIRECT CUSTOMER ORIENTED SIGNAGE FOR THE ONLINE SALES ACTIVITIES SHALL BE ALLOWED.

AND AGAIN, YOU'LL SEE THE NUMBER 9 NEXT TO OUTDOOR COURTS BECAUSE EVERYTHING SHIFTS DOWN A NUMBER.

TEXT AMENDMENT NUMBER 3 IS FOR 10-6.2. THE USE CATEGORIES DEFINITION.

THIS LIMITED ONLINE SALES WAS ADDED TO ACCESSORY USES.

AND THE DEFINITION IS A COMMERCIAL USE INVOLVING THE ONLINE SALES OF EXCLUSIVE GOODS, PRODUCTS AND OR SERVICES IN WHICH ALL FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS ARE CONDUCTED ELECTRONICALLY AND NO IN-PERSON SALES, CUSTOMER VISITS, ON SITE ADVERTISEMENT OR SOLICITATION OCCUR.

ALL GOODS, PRODUCTS OR SERVICES ARE RECEIVED DIGITALLY OR DELIVERED EXCLUSIVELY TO CUSTOMERS AT OFF SITE PREMISES LOCATIONS.

THIS IS IN REFERENCE TO THE DIFFERENT CITIES ACROSS AMERICA THAT INTENDED TO DO THE SAME.

YOU HAVE OGDEN, UTAH, WHERE THEY ADDED TO THEIR CODE AUTOMOBILE SALES ONLY ONLINE AND IT'S RELEVANT TO THE MUSEUM COLLECTOR, HAVING A MUSEUM ON SITE AND SELLING THEIR ITEMS OFFLINE, SELLING THEIR ITEMS OFF SITE.

THE SAME IS FOR THE CITY OF INGLEWOOD. THEY ADDED TO THEIR ZONING CODE AMENDMENT IN 2014.

THE USED AMENDMENT IS INCLUDING SALES ONLINE ONLY.

YOU ALSO HAVE WATERFORD TOWNSHIP IN MINNESOTA.

IN 2019, THEY AMENDED THEIR ORDINANCE TO READ THE USE ONLINE SALES FOR AUCTIONS.

AND ALSO, NUMBER 4, YOU HAVE BURLINGTON TOWNSHIP, MICHIGAN.

[00:35:02]

THEY UPDATED THEIR ZONING ORDINANCE FOR THE USE ONLINE SALES.

ALL CITIES ARE. THIS IS ALL RELATIVE BECAUSE THE APPROACH IS FOR ONLINE SALES AND NO ON SITE RETAIL ACTIVITY, IN THE LINE OF CODE OR CONDITIONS. AND AT LEAST TWO CITIES, OGDEN, UTAH AND INGLEWOOD, CALIFORNIA, HAVE APPLIED IT TO SPECIFIC TO VEHICLE SALES.

THIS IS A ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF TAMARAC. AND AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE SQUARED AWAY AREAS, THAT'S WHERE OUR MAIN CORRIDORS ARE. SO YOU HAVE COMMERCIAL BOULEVARD 441.

YOU HAVE UNIVERSITY DRIVE, MCNAB ROAD. THOSE ARE OUR MAJOR CORRIDORS.

AND THAT'S WHERE WE INTEND TO APPLY ALL OF THE LIMITED ONLINE SALES IN ALL FOUR DISTRICTS.

THIS IS AN AERIAL OF THE PATINA COLLECTIVE. AGAIN, PATINA COLLECTIVE, THEY ARE AN AUTOMOBILE MUSEUM SPECIFIC FOR ENTHUSIASTS OF MERCEDES BENZ. PEOPLE THAT ARE GOING THERE ARE VERY, YOU KNOW, ECSTATIC ABOUT, YOU KNOW, HAVING THE ABILITY TO SEE 80S AND 90S MERCEDES BENZ AUTOMOBILES.

AND THIS IS A VERY EXCLUSIVE USE, AND IT'S BY APPOINTMENT ONLY, IN REFERENCE TO YOUR QUESTION EARLIER.

EVERYTHING IS BY APPOINTMENT ONLY. YOU CAN'T JUST WALK IN, GO IN THERE AND YOU KNOW, AS A TYPICAL MUSEUM, YOU HAVE TO SCHEDULE. THIS IS A PHOTO OF THE REAR.

IT REFLECTS TWO GARAGE DOORS FOR THE CAR ENTRIES.

AND THIS IS THEIR LOCATION AGAIN, WHERE THE CARS ARE GOING TO BE ENTERED.

ENTRANCE AND EXITS. [INAUDIBLE] ALREADY EXPLAINED THE FLOOR PLAN.

I'M JUST SHOWING YOU THE ENTRANCE IS AT THE TOP, YOU HVE TWO GARAGE DOORS ARE AT THE BOTTOM, AND YOU HAVE FIVE EXITS AROUND THE PERIMETER OF THE BUILDING.

AND THESE ARE THE REVIEW STANDARDS FOR ESTABLISHMENT OF USE.

THERE ARE FIVE STANDARDS TO BE MET. AND WITH ALL FIVE STANDARDS, THE DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT HAS DETERMINED THAT THE ESTABLISHED CRITERIA FOR GRANTING OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF USE AND TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE HAVE BEEN MET.

THE ESTABLISHMENT OF USE SUPPORTS THE CITY'S 2040 STRATEGIC PLAN, GOAL NUMBER THREE.

TAMARAC IS ECONOMICALLY RESILIENT BY BEING BUSINESS FRIENDLY AND ESTABLISHING LAND DEVELOPMENT POLICIES THAT ARE RESPONSIVE TO EVOLVING INDUSTRY NEEDS.

THE CITY WILL CONTINUE TO FOSTER PRO GROWTH DEVELOPMENT PRACTICES THAT WILL NOT ONLY RETAIN, BUT ALSO ATTRACT NEW AND CREATIVE BUSINESS VENTURES TO THE CITY OF TAMARAC.

THE APPLICANT'S REQUEST FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF USE IS CONSISTENT WITH THE FOLLOWING POLICIES OF THE CITY'S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT, OBJECTIVE 1, POLICY 1.4 AND FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT OBJECTIVE 1, POLICY 10.8.

BOTH POLICIES ARE PROVIDED IN STAFF MEMORANDUM.

AND THE RECOMMENDATION. THE DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT RECOMMENDS THAT THE PLANNING BOARD FORWARD A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION OF APPROVAL FOR THE PROPOSED ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING LIMITED ONLINE SALES AS AN ACCESSORY USE IN THE MUN, MIXED USE NEIGHBORHOOD, MUC, MIXED USE CORRIDOR, MUG, MIXED USE GENERAL, AND NC, NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL ZONING DISTRICTS.

ALSO AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 3, SECTION 10-3.2 ENTITLED TABLE OF ALLOWED USES SPECIFICALLY.

TABLE 10-3.1 ALLOWED USES FOR THE INCLUSION OF LIMITED ONLINE SALES.

ALSO, AMENDING SECTION 10-3.4 ENTITLED ACCESSORY USES AND STRUCTURES TO PROVIDE THE USE SPECIFIC STANDARDS REGULATING THE LIMITED ONLINE SALES USE AND AMENDING CHAPTER 10, ARTICLE 6 ENTITLED RULES OF CONSTRUCTION AND DEFINITIONS SPECIFICALLY 10-6.2, SUBSECTION E, ENTITLED ACCESSORY USES OF THE CITY OF TAMARAC CODE OF ORDINANCES TO PROVIDE A DEFINITION FOR LIMITED ONLINE SALES.

THIS IS MY PRESENTATION. I'D BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.

THANK YOU SO MUCH. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD? YES, A QUICK QUESTION. I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S FOR YOU OR FOR THE GENTLEMAN THERE.

SO YOU'RE SAYING THE TOTAL SALES WILL BE 5%, RIGHT? IS THAT OF THE INVENTORY ON HAND OR INVENTORY GENERAL? AND WHAT IS THE INVENTORY THAT YOU HAVE? TOTAL NUMBER OF VEHICLES ARE 300.

THAT'S IT, SO.

OKAY. THANK YOU. YOU'RE WELCOME. WHERE ARE THE REST OF YOUR VEHICLES STORED? IF THEY'RE NOT ON THIS SITE, THEY'RE ON THE BOCA RATON LOCATION FOR THAT.

THAT IS OWNED BY AN AFFILIATE [INAUDIBLE]. OH, IT IS TIED TO ANOTHER CAR DEALERSHIP? YOUR BUSINESS IS TIED. THAT LOCATION DOES HAVE A ONLINE VEHICLE LICENSE.

VEHICLE DEALERSHIP LICENSE. OKAY, GREAT. ALL RIGHT.

THANK YOU. YOU'RE WELCOME. I HAVE A QUESTION FOR THE CITY.

[00:40:06]

JUST OUT OF CURIOSITY, WHAT WAS THIS? I KNOW THIS IS FOR AN ACCESSORY USE, BUT FOR ONLINE SALES, IF AN OWNER WANTED TO DO ONLINE SALES, WHAT WOULD THAT BE CATEGORIZED AS? IF THEY HAVE A STOREFRONT? AND WOULD THAT JUST BE RETAIL, OR WHAT WAS IT BEFORE? YES. BECAUSE I KNOW EVERYBODY'S DOING IT. SO, YOU KNOW, THIS TO ME IS.

IT DOESN'T APPLY ACROSS THE BOARD. THIS IS SPECIFIC FOR LIKE VERY SPECIFIC USES.

THIS IS A CAR MUSEUM THAT IS SELLING VEHICLES OFF SITE.

SO THEREFORE WE WANTED TO ADD IT TO THE CODE SO WE CAN AT LEAST LIMIT OR REGULATE THESE TYPE OF USES.

SO IT'S NOT ACROSS THE BOARD FOR ALL USES. I UNDERSTAND, BUT WOULD THEY JUST BE CLASSIFIED AS A BUSINESS USE? LIKE IF I OPENED A BUSINESS. JUST A BUSINESS.

LET ME ATTEMPT TO RESPOND TO THAT. YES. SO THE PRINCIPAL USE WOULD BE THE BUSINESS THAT'S OPERATING.

THIS IS INCIDENTAL. IF THEY ARE DOING ANY ONLINE SALES THAT WOULD ALLOW FOR SOME VIEWING AT THE LOCATION.

SO I SPOKE TO MAHER BEFORE WE GOT HERE THIS MORNING.

THERE'S A BIT OF AN UPDATING THAT WE NEED TO DO TO THE PRESENTATION THAT WAS DELIVERED TO YOU, BUT IT WILL ALLOW THE BUSINESS. FOR EXAMPLE, IF THE RETAIL BUSINESS COMES IN THEIR BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT, THEIR ZONING CLASSIFICATION, THEIR PRINCIPAL USE WOULD BE THAT RETAIL BUSINESS.

IF THEY'RE THEN DOING SOME ONLINE SALES, THAT REQUIRES THE CUSTOMER TO COME IN AND DO SOME VIEWING IN THE STORE AND THEN PURCHASE ONLINE, THEN THAT ONLINE SALE WOULD BE INCIDENTAL TO THEIR PRINCIPAL USE.

SO, AS CHRISTIAN MENTIONED, ALTHOUGH WE HAVE AN APPLICANT SPECIFIC TO PATINA COLLECTION, WE ARE EXPANDING THE TEXT AMENDMENT TO BE APPLICABLE IN ALL THE ZONING DISTRICTS THAT WERE LISTED IN THE PRESENTATION.

SO IT WOULD NOT JUST BE FOR PATINA COLLECTION.

WHICH THAT PROVIDES MORE FLEXIBILITY FOR THE CITY OF TAMARAC AS IT RELATES TO GENERATING INCOME FOR THE CITY, IF I'M UNDERSTANDING CORRECTLY. AND IT'S A NEW TYPE OF COMMERCE, WE'RE SEEING MORE AND MORE BUSINESSES THAT ARE ENGAGING IN ONLINE SALES.

THE CUSTOMER MAY COME INTO THE STORE AND VIEW THE PRODUCT OR SEE THE PRODUCT, BUT THEN IS COORDINATING THE SALE ONLINE.

AND SO WE WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE PROVIDED FOR THAT.

AND PROVIDING MORE BUSINESS INTO BROWARD COUNTY AS WELL AS THE CARS ARE IMPORTED IN AND OUT.

SO YEAH, IT'S A LARGER PICTURE. I DO AGREE AND UNDERSTAND.

I KNOW THERE'S A LOT OF BUSINESSES OPERATING NOW UNDER THAT BUSINESS MODEL.

SO I JUST WANTED SOME CLARIFICATION ON THAT. MY SECOND THING IS JUST TO CONFIRM.

NO DISPLAY OF GOODS TO BE ALLOWED, SO THE CARS WILL BE.

I COULDN'T SEE THE PLAN REAL WELL BEHIND. WILL IT BE IN A CLOSED AREA? FROM YOUR PLAN, CAN YOU BRING THE PLAN BACK UP ON THE SCREEN FOR ME? YES. THERE'S NO DISPLAY EXTERNAL TO THE BUILDING, SO ALL THE VEHICLES WOULD BE INTERNAL.

OKAY, I SEE. NO, THERE'S A WALL BETWEEN. OKAY.

YEAH. EVERYTHING'S ENCLOSED FROM THE FRONT TO THE BACK.

EVERYTHING IS INSIDE OF THE BUILDING ITSELF. OKAY, SO TYPICAL FROM THE SHOW AREA.

YOU KNOW, THEY'RE WALKING AROUND AND. YEAH. OKAY, SO THERE IS A WALL AND THERE'S A RESTRICTED AREA FOR THAT.

SO WE JUST WANT TO MAKE THAT DISTINCTION BECAUSE IT'S CARS.

SO IN YOUR TYPICAL CAR SALE ENVIRONMENT YOU'LL SEE DISPLAYS EXTERNAL CARS THAT ARE PARKED AND IT'S DISPLAYED OUTSIDE.

SO WE JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE CAPTURED THAT.

ALL RIGHT. I HAVE ANOTHER QUESTION. WHAT TYPE OF SECURITY MEASURES ARE NEEDED FOR THIS PARTICULAR MUSEUM AS IT RELATES TO OUR CITY? WOULD YOU MIND. SO WHAT TYPE OF SECURITY WILL BE NEEDED TO SECURE YOUR BUILDING IN THE VEHICLES? AS OF RIGHT NOW, I GUESS WHAT'S IN PLACE OR WHAT IS DETERMINED TO BE NEEDED.

SO I WOULD HAVE TO CONSULT WITH THE OWNER TO GET DETAILS ON THAT.

ASIDE FROM STANDARD SECURITY MEASURES, I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING SPECIFIC TO OFFER ON THAT.

OKAY. BUT WE WILL DEFINITELY BE COORDINATING WITH THE CITY TO MAKE SURE THAT WHATEVER WE DO IS GOING TO MAKE SENSE FROM A PUBLIC SAFETY PERSPECTIVE.

WONDERFUL. THANK YOU. THIS IS TREATED AS JUST A RETAIL SALES OR A MUSEUM.

THERE ARE NO SPECIFIC SECURITY MEASURES THAT WE INVOKE ON THE APPLICANT APPLICANT.

SO YEAH, OUTSIDE OF CCTV, IF THEY WANTED TO PROVIDE MORE SECURITY, THEY CAN IF THEY PLEASE.

OKAY. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU, CHRISTINE.

[00:45:04]

WITH NO OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD, WE'LL OPEN PUBLIC HEARING.

I'M SEEING NONE. WE'LL CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING.

OKAY. CAN WE NOW ASK FOR A MOTION TO APPROVE OR DENY THIS ITEM? ARE WE GOING BY SECTIONS OR WE'RE. HOW ARE WE ADDRESSING THE ACCESSORY OF USE? IT'S JUST ONE MOTION. CORRECT. IT'S JUST ONE.

IT'S JUST ONE. OKAY. I MOTION TO APPROVE THIS ITEM.

I SECOND IT. ALEXANDRA ALVAREZ. YES. SAJEEN BELL-CLARK.

YES. JACQUES MOISE. YES. MARA ENGLISH. YES. ATHERLEY SOMAN.

YES. JUDY HUNTER. YES. MOTION TO MAKE A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO THE CITY COMMISSION PASSED 6 TO 0.

THANK YOU GUYS. THANK YOU ALL VERY MUCH. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU. THANK YOU. WELCOME TO TAMARAC. YES.

HOPEFULLY, I GET TO HAVE ONE OF THOSE PRIVATE MEETINGS.

THANK YOU. AND WITH THAT, WE'LL NOW MOVE ON TO QUASI JUDICIAL HEARING 9.A.

[9.a TBO100 - Board Order approving/denying application for special exception to allow for a proposed packaged liquor store in the NC (Neighborhood Commercial) zoning district pursuant to Section 10-3.2, Table of Allowed Uses, Code of Ordinances at 7158 North Nob Hill Road, Tamarac, Florida 33321.]

TEMPORARY BOARD ORDER 100, BOARD ORDER APPROVING OR DENYING APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL EXCEPTION TO ALLOW FOR A PROPOSED PACKAGE LIQUOR STORE IN THE NC NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL ZONING DISTRICT PURSUANT TO SECTION 10-3.2 TABLE OF ALLOWED USES CODE OF ORDINANCE AT 7158 NORTH NOB HILL ROAD, TAMARAC, FLORIDA. 33321.

WE'LL NOW HAVE THE APPLICANT PRESENTATION. GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE, AND THANK YOU FOR COMING. MY NAME IS [INAUDIBLE]. BUT MY FRIENDS AND CUSTOMERS ARE CALLING ME [INAUDIBLE].

I AM THE OWNER OF [INAUDIBLE] INC. I HAVE WITH ME MISTER [INAUDIBLE], OWNER AND PRESIDENT OF [INAUDIBLE]. INDEED, WE HAVE ALREADY SUBMITTED ALL REQUIRED DOCUMENTS TO THE CITY AND ACCEPTED.

THEREFORE, MISTER [INAUDIBLE] IS GOING OVER THE PROJECT PRESENTATION.

AFTER, WE WILL RESPECTFULLY ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.

MISTER [INAUDIBLE].

GOOD MORNING, BOARD AND RESIDENTS OF TAMARAC.

MY NAME IS [INAUDIBLE]. I AM THE GENERAL CONTRACTOR AND ENGINEER OF RECORD FOR THE PROPOSED LIQUOR STORE.

OKAY. [INAUDIBLE] LIQUORS. SPECIAL EXCEPTION PRESENTATION.

AS YOU HAVE JUST MET [INAUDIBLE], HE'S THE OWNER OF THE CORPORATION, AND PROPOSING TO PUT A LOCATION INTO ONE OF YOUR SHOPPING CENTERS IN TAMARAC. THE SPACE IS APPROXIMATELY 1100 AND 90FT², AND WE WILL BE PROPOSING A BUILD OUT AS PER THE PLAN THAT WAS SUBMITTED TO THE CITY FOR THE RETAIL SERVICE. THE PROPERTY FEATURES PARKING IN THE FRONT BACK IN BOTH SIDES OF THE BUILDING.

THE OPERATING HOURS WILL BE NONDAY THROUGH THURSDAY, 11 A.M.

TO 10 P.M., FRIDAY AND SATURDAY FROM 11 A.M. TO 11 P.M., AND SUNDAY FROM 12 P.M.

TO 9 P.M. THE OPERATING HOURS MAY VARY DEPENDING ON THE CITY'S NOTICES AND APPROVALS, OR ANY CHANGES THAT COME FORTH.

THIS IS A SCREENSHOT OF THE FRONT DOOR ENTRANCE.

IT HAPPENS TO BE RIGHT BY AN ADA PARKING SPOT.

THIS IS THE REAR DELIVERY, BACKDOOR EXIT AND EMERGENCY EXIT AND REAR DELIVERY FOR PRODUCTS THAT COME IN TO BE STORED ON THE SHELVING.

PICTURE OF THE FRONT PARKING. AMPLE PARKING. BACK PARKING AS WELL FOR EMPLOYEES AND OVERRUN FROM THE FRONT FOR CUSTOMERS IF NEEDED.

THE LOCATION OF THE SPACE IS. WHERE IS IT? THE STORE IS LOCATED IN THE POINT PLAZA IN TAMARAC STREET ON NOB HILL ROAD, NORTH OF WEST WOOD DRIVE AND SOUTH OF NORTH BELFORD CIRCLE.

THESE ARE THE NEAREST SENSITIVE LOCATIONS THAT WE WERE ABLE TO COME UP WITH.

CHALLENGER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL IS 7920FT FROM THE PROPOSED LIQUOR STORE.

SUNSET POINT PARK IS 5280FT FROM THE PROPOSED LIQUOR STORE, AND THE NEAREST LIQUOR STORE THAT WE'VE COME UP WITH WAS TAMARAC DISCOUNT LIQUORS,

[00:50:03]

WHICH IS 12,672FT FROM THE PROPOSED LIQUOR STORE.

THE PURPOSE OF THE LIQUOR STORE. SERVING THE PEOPLE'S DEMANDS.

A LIQUOR STORE PROVIDES REGULATED ACCESS TO A WIDELY ACCEPTED PRODUCT THAT MANY ADULTS CONSUME RESPONSIBLY FOR SOCIAL, CULTURAL, AND PERSONAL ENJOYMENT. PROMOTE CONVENIENCE AND ACCESSIBILITY.

LOCATING A LIQUOR STORE WITHIN A COMMUNITY PROVIDES EASY AND CONVENIENT ACCESS TO ALCOHOL, PREVENTING INDIVIDUALS FROM THE NEEDING TO TRAVEL LONG DISTANCES AND DECREASING THE RISK OF DRIVING WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCE.

STIMULATING THE LOCAL ECONOMY. AS A LOCAL BUSINESS [INAUDIBLE] LIQUORS WILL CONTRIBUTE TO THE LOCAL ECONOMY BY CREATING JOBS, PAYING LOCAL TAXES, AND SUPPORTING THE CITY CHARITABLE EVENTS AND ANY OTHER NEARBY BUSINESSES.

PROVIDING AN ESSENTIAL SERVICE. DURING THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC, LIQUOR STORES HAVE BEEN RECOGNIZED AS ESSENTIAL BUSINESSES, HIGHLIGHTING THEIR ROLE IN PROVIDING COMFORT AND CONSISTENCY TO CUSTOMERS DURING UNCERTAIN TIMES.

LIQUOR IS ESSENTIAL BECAUSE MANY PEOPLE BELIEVE IT IS ESSENTIAL TO THEM.

SAFETY. STRICT PROTOCOL FOR EMPLOYEES TO CHECK PHOTO IDS BEFORE ANY ATTEMPTED PURCHASES.

INTOXICATED INDIVIDUALS ARE FORBIDDEN TO BUY ALCOHOL FROM THE ESTABLISHMENT.

DELIVERIES WILL BE BROUGHT IN FROM THE REAR OF THE BUILDING.

THE STORE WILL BE CLOSED DURING DELIVERY HOURS TO ALLOW FOR FULL INVENTORY CONTROL AND INVENTORY RECEIPT CONFIRMATION BEFORE THE PRODUCT IS PUT ON THE SHELVES.

THE STORE ROOM, OFFICE, AND COOLER DOORS WILL BE SECURED IN WAYS THAT WILL NOT ALLOW NON-EMPLOYEES TO ACCESS THE STORAGE AREAS FOR SAFETY.

SECURITY. A MULTI-CAMERA CCTV SYSTEM TO COVER ALL PARTS OF THE STORE AND THE SYSTEMS WILL HAVE REMOTE MONITORING CAPABILITIES FOR MOBILE DEVICES.

VIDEO SURVEILLANCE OF POINT OF SALE STATIONS AT THE FRONT COUNTERS AND CAMERAS WILL INCLUDE SENSORS, DETECTION AND NIGHT VISION. EMPLOYEE TRAINING.

MANDATORY PARTICIPATION IN ONLINE COURSES AND SEMINARS THAT STRESS THE IMPORTANCE OF SAFETY MEASURES REGARDING UNDERAGE DRINKING, SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND ALCOHOL ABUSE, AND HOW TO VERIFY A LICENSE AND WHEN TO DENY A SALE.

SPECIAL EXCEPTION REVIEW STANDS ARTICLE 5, SECTION 10-5.4 G.4.

THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WILL BE CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN.

THE TAMARAC COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IS A ROADMAP GUIDING THE CITY'S GROWTH, DEVELOPMENT AND POLICY DECISIONS.

THE LIQUOR STORE IS CONSISTENT WITH THE PLAN AND WILL WILL PROVIDE A VARIED OF DIVERSE MIX OF COMMERCIAL OPPORTUNITIES TO SERVE THE RESIDENTS OF THE CITY.

THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE RETAIL LIQUOR STORE IN A VIBRANT SHOPPING CENTER WILL ATTRACT RESIDENTS OF THE CITY.

THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WILL COMPLY WITH APPLICABLE ZONING DISTRICTS USE AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS OF THE CODE.

IT IS IN ITS CURRENT FORM, AS PER 10-2.3 2 B, THE DISTRICT ENCOURAGES THE DEVELOPMENT OF MIXED USE ACTIVITY CENTERS ALONG THE CITY'S ROADWAYS. THE DISTRICT ACCOMMODATES RETAIL, OFFICE, CULTURAL, ENTERTAINMENT, SERVICES AND INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENTS THAT MEET LOCAL NEEDS AND ALLOW FOR A POSITIVE VIEW OF THE CITY. THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WILL BE COMPATIBLE WITH ITS EXISTING NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND COMMUNITY.

CHARACTERS OF THE PROPERTIES WITHIN THE IMMEDIATE NEIGHBORHOOD LIKE STATED ABOVE.

THE PROPOSED LOCATION OF THE LIQUOR STORE IS A SPECIAL SUITE FROM POINT PLAZA.

THAT IS SURROUNDED BY OTHER COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES AND WILL COMPLY WITH THE DESIGN.

OF THE AREA. THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WILL BE DESIRABLE FOR PUBLIC CONVENIENCE AND NOT INJURIOUS OR OTHERWISE DETRIMENTAL TO PUBLIC HEALTH, SAFETY, COMFORT, AND WELFARE. THE LIQUOR STORE WILL ALLOW THESE OF AGE TO PURCHASE LIQUOR CONVENIENTLY AND PURCHASE ALCOHOL LOCALLY.

EMPLOYEE TRAINING WILL INCLUDE MANDATORY PARTICIPATION IN ONLINE COURSES AND SEMINARS THAT STRESS THE IMPORTANCE OF SAFETY MEASURES REGARDING UNDERAGE DRINKING AND SUBSTANCE AND ALCOHOL ABUSE. EMPLOYEES WILL LEARN HOW TO VERIFY A LICENSE AND WHEN TO DENY A SALE.

THE PURPOSE OF THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WILL MINIMIZE ADVERSE EFFECTS INCLUDING NOISE, LIGHT, DUST OR OTHER POTENTIAL NUISANCES ON ADJACENT PROPERTIES TO THE GREATEST EXTENT PRACTICABLE.

THE LIQUOR STORE WILL NOT HAVE ADVERSE IMPACTS ON NEARBY PROPERTIES AND WILL NOT BE DETRIMENTAL IN ITS USE AND PEACEFUL ENJOYMENT.

NO LIGHT, DUST, NOISE OR OTHER POTENTIAL NUISANCES WILL NEGATIVELY IMPACT NEARBY PROPERTIES.

THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WILL INCLUDE ADEQUATE PROVISIONS FOR SAFE AND CONVENIENT VEHICULAR AND PEDESTRIAN TRAFFIC MOVEMENT TO, FROM, AND THROUGH THE SITE THAT MAXIMIZES TRAFFIC CONGESTION AND MINIMIZES TRAFFIC CONGESTION IN THE PUBLIC STREETS.

[00:55:04]

THERE WILL BE NO IMPACT ON TRAFFIC, AS THE RETAIL STORE IS WITHIN AN EXISTING SHOPPING CENTER, WHICH MEETS ALL TRAFFIC AND PARKING REQUIREMENTS.

NO CHANGES TO THE EXISTING STRUCTURE OF THE PROPERTY WILL BE MADE.

THE SITE AREA IS SUFFICIENT, APPROXIMATE AND ADEQUATE.

I'M SORRY. THE SITE AREA IS SUFFICIENT, APPROPRIATE AND ADEQUATE FOR THE USE AND ANY RESPONSIBILITY.

ANTICIPATED EXPANSION OF THE USE. THE AREA IS SUFFICIENT AND APPROPRIATE AND ADEQUATE FOR ITS USE AS A LIQUOR STORE, AND COMPLIES WITH THE FUTURE LAND USE OF THIS SITE AS WELL.

THE SPECIAL EXCEPTION SHALL ONLY REMAIN VALID DURING THE PERIOD OF WHICH THE CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY AND BUSINESS LICENSES REMAIN ACTIVE.

I INTEND TO KEEP THE OCCUPANCY OF THE BUSINESS CERTIFICATION AND LICENSES ACTIVE TO ALLOW THE USE OF THIS SITE FOR FORESEEABLE FUTURE.

THE SPECIAL EXCEPTION IS TRANSFERABLE ADMINISTRATIVELY PURSUANT TO COMPLIANCE WITH THE CITY CODE.

SUBMITTING DOCUMENTATIONS AND PAYMENTS OF FEES ONLY AFTER THE PREVIOUS CONDITIONS HAVE BEEN MET.

I INTEND TO COMPLETE PAYMENTS OF FEES AND IMPLEMENT CONDITIONS IN A TIMELY MANNER.

ANY PREEXISTING CODE VIOLATIONS SHALL BE SATISFIED BEFORE CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY IS ISSUED FOR THE PROPOSED USE.

I INTEND TO RESOLVE ANY VIOLATIONS IN A TIMELY MANNER TO ALLOW THE CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY.

IN CONCLUSION, [INAUDIBLE] LIQUORS, INC. COMPLIES WITH THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPROVAL AND RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS A FAVORABLE REVIEW AND CONSIDERATION OF THIS APPLICATION FOR THE 7158 NORTH NOB HILL ROAD LOCATION.

THANK YOU. THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD? NO. THANK YOU. I WILL WAIT UNTIL THE CITY PRESENTS.

THE CITY'S PRESENTATION IS PRETTY MUCH CONSISTENT WITH THE APPLICANT.

WE'LL JUST ENTER IT INTO THE RECORD, UNLESS THIS BOARD STILL WANTS TO SEE IT.

BUT THE APPLICANT WAS VERY DETAILED WITH ALL THE CONDITIONS, AND.

OKAY. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. WE'LL ENTER STAFF'S PRESENTATION INTO THE RECORD.

SO NOW I GUESS WE WILL HEAR FROM THE. OPEN PUBLIC HEARING.

WE HAVE [INAUDIBLE], CAN YOU PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS? GOOD MORNING. GOOD MORNING. [INAUDIBLE] 9838 SOUTH BELFORT CIRCLE, TAMARAC.

THANK YOU. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES TO. OKAY. STATISTICALLY, NEIGHBORHOODS WITH LIQUOR STORES ARE ASSOCIATED WITH HIGHER CRIME RATES, ASSAULT, ROBBERY, SHOPLIFTING, AND VIOLENT CRIMES.

KIDS MIGHT LOITER IN THE FRONT ASKING ADULTS TO PURCHASE LIQUOR.

ALCOHOL CAN IMPAIR JUDGMENT AND INCREASE AGGRESSION.

WHAT IF SOMEBODY GOES INTO LIQUOR STORE ALREADY INEBRIATED AND STARTS AN ALTERCATION? HAVING A LIQUOR STORE THIS CLOSE TO A RESIDENTIAL AREA MIGHT DEVALUE THE NEIGHBORING PROPERTIES.

JOHNS HOPKINS STUDY FOUND THAT FOR EVERY 10% INCREASE IN ACCESS TO A LIQUOR STORE, THERE WAS A 4.2 INCREASE IN VIOLENT CRIMES.

CRIMES ARE MORE CONCENTRATED NEAR ALCOHOL OUTLETS.

IN SOME STUDIES, ONE STUDY FOUND THAT CRIME LEVELS WERE HIGHEST WITHIN 85FT.

ANOTHER STUDY SHOWS IT WAS ASSOCIATED WITH SIGNIFICANTLY MORE POLICE PHONE CALLS.

TAMARAC CRIMES PER SQUARE MILE. THE NATIONAL MEDIAN IS 26.5.

TAMARAC IS AT 81%. THE OVERALL CRIME RATE IS HIGHER THAN THE NATIONAL AVERAGE.

ON JUNE 25TH, 2025, THE HIGHLIGHTED SIGNIFICANT PUBLIC SAFETY CONCERNS, PARTICULARLY REGARDING A 50% INCREASE IN VIOLENT CRIMES, AS REPORTED BY ACTING CAPTAIN CHRISTOPHER PALOMAR OF THE BROWARD COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE.

THE STATE EXPERIENCED OVER 4000 CALLS IN MAY ALONE.

THIS AREA IS NOT ZONED FOR LIQUOR STORE. THE PERSON IS ASKING FOR AN EXCEPTION.

IF YOU MAKE AN EXCEPTION FOR ONE PERSON, THEN IT LEAVES THE DOOR OPEN FOR MORE SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS.

IN ALL THE YEARS THIS PLAZA HAS BEEN THERE, THERE'S NEVER BEEN A LIQUOR STORE.

WHY WOULD YOU ENTERTAIN IT NOW? ON A PERSONAL NOTE, I USED TO LIVE IN THIS AREA.

IN 2015, I SOLD MY HOME IN WATERFORD ISLE DUE TO THE BREAK INS IN MY COMMUNITY AND THE CRIME LEVEL IN TAMARAC.

DUE TO CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH I WON'T GET INTO NOW AND BORE YOU WITH, I AM BACK IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD AND HONESTLY,

[01:00:08]

I DO NOT FEEL SAFE HERE. IF I HAD A CHOICE I WOULD LEAVE, BUT UNFORTUNATELY I CAN'T.

HE ALREADY PUT HIS NOISE CONTROL. WILL THERE BE SECURITY OUTSIDE OF THE LIQUOR STORE, AND THERE ARE OTHER PLACES TO BUY LIQUOR IN TAMARAC.

AS HE STATED, THERE IS A LIQUOR STORE CLOSE. YOU'VE GOT PUBLIX, YOU'VE GOT WALMART.

WHEN SPEAKING WITH MY OTHER NEIGHBORS, THEY WERE NOT IN FAVOR OF THIS.

UNFORTUNATELY, THEY DIDN'T SHOW UP TO VOICE THEIR OPINION.

SO I THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND CONSIDERATION OF NOT PUTTING THIS PROPOSED STORE HERE 400FT TO WHERE I LIVE.

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT. GOOD DAY. ANYONE ELSE FOR PUBLIC HEARING? NOPE? OKAY. WE'LL CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING AT THE TIME.

DO WE HAVE ANYTHING FROM THE BOARD AGAIN? NOPE.

OKAY, HERE WE GO AHEAD AND ASK FOR A MOTION TO APPROVE OR DENY THIS ITEM.

SECOND. CAN THE APPLICANT COME BACK TO US? YES, IF HE WANTS TO RESPOND TO THE. OKAY. POINTS. THANK YOU FOR VOICING YOUR OPINIONS.

IF NEED BE, IF THE BOARD REQUESTS, WE CAN PUT SECURITY CAMERAS ON THE EXTERIOR OF THE BUILDING ON OUR SPACE TO POINT DIRECTLY TO THE DOORS AND THE PARKING AREAS WITHIN, IF IT'S ALLOWED TO THE PARKING AREAS WITHIN THE SPACE AND THE BACK DOORS.

WE'RE ALREADY GOING TO HAVE IT ON THE INSIDE, BUT WE CAN DO IT ON THE OUTSIDE IF THE BOARD REQUESTS. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU. LET'S GO BACK FOR ASKING FOR A MOTION TO APPROVE OR DENY THIS ITEM.

ANYONE? OKAY. AND IF YOU'RE NOT READY TO HAVE A DISCUSSION, YOU CAN START BY JUST DISCUSSING IT AND THEN MAYBE THAT'LL HELP YOU GET TO A MOTION. ANYONE? IS THERE ANY ORDINANCE THAT SAYS IN THE PROXIMITY OF HOW CLOSE ANOTHER LIQUOR STORE SHOULD BE TO ANOTHER LIQUOR STORE? AND HOW DO YOU KNOW WHAT THE DEMAND IS? HOW DO YOU DETERMINE THE DEMAND FOR ANOTHER LIQUOR STORE? BECAUSE IT APPEARS THAT THIS ONE IS IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO ANOTHER.

I'M JUST TRYING TO UNDERSTAND. YEAH, WELL, IT IS NOT IN A CLOSE PROXIMITY.

I THINK IN THE APPLICANT'S PRESENTATION, THEY GAVE YOU THE DISTANCE.

SO IT'S NOT. BUT YES, THE CODE DOES PROVIDE FOR A DISTANCE SEPARATION OF 1000FT, NOT JUST FROM ANOTHER LIQUOR STORE, BUT ALSO FROM PARKS, SCHOOLS, ELEMENTARY, MIDDLE SCHOOL, HIGH SCHOOL.

AND THE PROPOSED LOCATION WAS NOT WITHIN THE 1000FT.

IT IS ALSO APPROPRIATELY ZONED. SO I JUST WANTED TO RESPOND TO THE SPEAKER.

SO THIS IS NOT A ZONING APPLICATION. IT'S A SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPLICATION, WHICH IS ONE OF THOSE USES BECAUSE OF ITS UNIQUENESS.

IT REQUIRES ADDITIONAL REVIEW AS WELL AS CONDITIONS.

AND SO THAT'S WHY YOU'RE HERE IN THIS ITEM. IT'S A SPECIAL EXCEPTION.

SO THE LOCATION IS APPROPRIATELY ZONED. THE PLAZA CAN FACILITATE THIS USE.

THE PLAZA CURRENTLY I THINK HAS A VACANCY OF ABOUT 10 OR 15.

THERE'S LIKE TWO BAYS THAT ARE VACANT. TEN OR SO PERCENT VACANCY.

I SAW ABOUT 85 TO 90% OCCUPIED. AND ONCE AGAIN IS ZONED FOR THIS USE, PROVIDED THE SPECIAL EXCEPTION IS GRANTED.

WHAT OTHER BUSINESSES ARE WITHIN THAT LOCATION? WE HAVE A MYRIAD. I THINK IT'S IN. CHRISTIAN, YOU CAN RESPOND.

FOR THE RECORD AGAIN, CHRISTIAN WATERVAL, PLANNER.

YOU HAVE MEDICAL FACILITIES, YOU HAVE INSURANCE OFFICE, YOU HAVE TWO RESTAURANTS.

THANK YOU, ROB. YEAH, YOU HAVE TWO RESTAURANTS, MEDICAL FACILITIES, A CONVENIENCE STORE DIRECTLY NEXT DOOR YOU HAVE A DRY CLEANER.

SO THERE ARE APPLICABLE USES AND RETAIL USES INSIDE THE PLAZA.

THERE'S A CONVENIENCE STORE THAT SELLS ALCOHOL. I DON'T.

OUTSIDE OF BEER, I DON'T RECALL. OKAY. AND THE SPEAKER MENTIONED, SO SHE SAID IT WOULD BE OPENING THE DOOR FOR OTHER SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS, BUT EACH SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPLICATION THAT COMES TO US WILL BE TREATED INDIVIDUALLY.

[01:05:06]

IT'S ON THEIR OWN MERIT. ABSOLUTELY. AND ONCE AGAIN, IT WOULD HAVE TO MEET THE DISTANCE SEPARATION.

SO CLEARLY ANOTHER LIQUOR STORE WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO BE WITHIN 1000FT OF THIS LOCATION.

OKAY. IF I MAY INTERJECT, THIS WAS A. THE LIQUOR STORES WERE WITHIN RETAIL SALES, SO IT WAS A PERMITTED USE OUTRIGHT.

IN 2023, YOU GUYS, ALONG WITH THE CITY COMMISSION, APPROVED THE AMENDMENT OF THE CODE TO ADD VAPE SMOKE SHOP, LIQUOR STORES AS A SPECIAL EXCEPTION IN FOUR ZONING DISTRICTS.

SO IT WAS APPROVED OCTOBER 25TH, 2023 CITY COMMISSION MEETING.

AND IN REGARDS TO YOUR OTHER QUESTION. THE DISTANCE FROM.

DISTANCE. SO AS FAR AS ACTUAL HARD LIQUOR STORES NOT JUST BEER AND WINE, BUT ACTUAL LIQUOR STORES, YOUR CLOSEST IS 6240FT, WHICH IS THE SOUTH GATE AND PINE ISLAND PUBLIX.

AND THE NEXT NEAREST IS 10,500FT, WHICH IS 5810 NORTH UNIVERSITY DRIVE.

THANK YOU. THIS GRAPH HELPED A LOT. THANK YOU.

ITEM BEFORE US. WELL, I THINK BASED ON THE PRESENTATION, WHEN IT COMES TO THE SCHOOL.

SO IT'S NOT REALLY TOO CLOSE BY THE SCHOOL. AND THEN THERE'S A FAR DISTANCE.

I THINK THE PRESENTATION WAS VERY DETAILED. I'M MAKING A MOTION TO APPROVE.

I SECOND THAT MOTION. I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR SPEAKING UP ON BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY.

AS FAR AS THE PRESENTATION AND AS A PLANNING BOARD MEMBER, I FEEL COMFORTABLE MOVING FORWARD, SECONDING THE MOTION SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY'VE TAKEN SPECIFIC PROTOCOLS TO ALSO ENSURE THAT THEY'RE NOT GOING TO PROVIDE ALCOHOL TO SOMEONE WHO IS ALREADY UNDER THE INFLUENCE. AND SO I APPRECIATE THAT.

AND I APPRECIATE THE OFFER TO SECURE THE AREA.

I AM AWARE THAT IN THAT PLAZA THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF VACANCIES FOR THE RETAIL SHOPS.

AND I DO FEEL THAT CONTINUING TO PUSH TAMARAC IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION, AS IT RELATES TO SMALL BUSINESSES AND SO FORTH IS APPROPRIATE.

SO THANK YOU. AND I MIGHT ALSO ADD THAT THE APPLICANT HAS MET ALL THE REQUIREMENTS BY THE CITY TO BE IN THIS AREA.

THE DISTANCE REQUIREMENTS, YOU KNOW, BEING THE SPECIAL EXCEPTION IN ZONE BY RIGHT.

SO JACQUES MOISE APPROVED AND ALEXANDRA SECONDED.

OKAY. MARA ENGLISH. YES. ATHERLEY SOMAN. YES.

JUDY HUNTER. YES. SAJEEN BELL-CLARK. YES. JACQUES MOISE.

YES. ALEXANDRA ALVAREZ. YES. MOTION TO MAKE A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO THE CITY COMMISSION, WITH CONDITIONS AS OUTLINED BY STAFF PASSED 6 TO 0.

THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR THAT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.

WE WILL NOW MOVE TO ITEM NINE B. YOU'RE WELCOME.

[9.b TBO101 - Board Order approving/denying application for variance seeking relief from Section 10-4.1 0(D)(3)(f)(iii), Code of Ordinances, to allow for two (2) fa~ade signs with one (1) fa~ade sign not located on the primary frontage of the tenant bay for a multiple tenant building with external access versus one (1) fa~ade sign per tenant bay located on the primary frontage of the tenant bay for a multiple tenant building with external access to the individual tenant bay permitted at 7613 NW 57 Street, Tamarac FL 33321.]

WELCOME TO TAMARA. ITEM 9.B. TEMPORARY BOARD ORDER 101.

BOARD ORDER APPROVING OR DENYING APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE SEEKING RELIEF FROM SECTION 10-4.1.

SECTION (D)(3)(F)(III), CODE OF ORDINANCES, TO ALLOW FOR TWO FACADE SIGNS AND ONE FACADE SIGN NOT LOCATED ON THE PRIMARY FRONTAGE OF THE TENANT BAY, FOR MULTIPLE TENANT BUILDING WITH EXTERNAL ACCESS VERSUS ONE FACADE SIGN PER TENANT BAY, LOCATED ON THE PRIMARY FRONTAGE OF THE TENANT BAY FOR A MULTIPLE TENANT BUILDING, WITH EXTERNAL ACCESS TO THE INDIVIDUAL TENANT BAY PERMITTED AT 7613 NW 57TH STREET, TAMARAC, FLORIDA 33321. WE'LL NOW HEAR FROM THE APPLICANT.

GOOD MORNING, PLANNING BOARD, CITY OFFICIALS AND COMMUNITY MEMBERS.

MY NAME IS RACHEL WILSON. I'M A CO-FOUNDER AND CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER OF BLUEBIRD KIDS HEALTH.

I'M ALSO THE DESIGNATED AGENT OF SO MIDWAY PLAZA JV, LLC, OUR LANDLORD.

I'M REALLY HAPPY TO BE HERE TODAY TO TALK ABOUT OUR REQUEST FOR A SECOND VARIANCE SIGN.

BUT BEFORE I MOVE INTO THAT DISCUSSION, I WANTED TO PROVIDE A LITTLE BIT OF CONTEXT ON MY ORGANIZATION, BLUEBIRD KIDS HEALTH. WE ARE A PEDIATRIC PRIMARY CARE ORGANIZATION.

WE FOCUS SPECIFICALLY ON CREATING ACCESS TO EXCEPTIONAL CARE IN COMMUNITIES THAT DON'T HAVE SUFFICIENT ACCESS TO PEDIATRIC CARE TODAY.

[01:10:08]

IN THE UNITED STATES, 1 IN 2 CHILDREN ARE ENROLLED IN MEDICAID.

IN FLORIDA, 6 IN 10. 60% OF THE CHILDREN. MEDICAID IS OFTEN NOT ONE OF THE BEST PAYERS OF HEALTHCARE SERVICES.